Why Index Funds score over ETFs?

Fi is a neobank aka online banking platform, that attempts to re-imagine the banking experience in India. The Fi account, in partnership with Federal Bank, is a digital bank account that gives you the fastest way to open a bank account online. Get periodic insights and monthly detailed reports about your investments, summarized for you with zero jargon. Investors get daily intimation of the portfolio of their investment. Investors also earn dividend income on the basis of ETFs, which they can further reinvest in the share market. On the taxation front, there is not much to choose between the two.

We currently offer over 70 ETFs on our platform, carefully selected to give you a wide exposure to the most common investing strategies or specific themes/sectors. Or investors may have to shell out a bounce trading strategy lump-sum amount while starting the investment. Index fund units can be sold as per individual preferences since these are open-ended. Let’s understand the key differences between Index funds and ETFs.

What is the difference between an ETF and a Mutual Fund?

You can simply select an index and invest in a low cost ETF, which tracks that index and your job is done. Like shares of a company, the units of the Gold ETFs are also traded on the stock exchange. ETFs, or exchange-traded funds, look a lot like index mutual funds except they trade on an exchange just like a stock or bond. Shares can be created when a broker/dealer acquires all of the underlying assets in the fund themselves and exchanges them directly with the ETF company for shares of the ETF. Shares can be redeemed in the same way — the ETF company will exchange all the underlying assets to retire shares of the fund.

How to choose between ETFs and index funds?

Since ETFs and index funds are similar, you might have trouble picking the right passive investment vehicle for you. In the end, the decision boils down to one’s trading style. ETFs, much like stocks, trade intraday. They are a good choice if you want to take advantage of price movements within the day.

Index funds will be a better option if you are not concerned about seizing intraday opportunities. Moreover, while you need to be well-versed with the trading process if you want to trade ETFs, that is not necessary with index funds.

A FREE assessment that tells you what kind of investor you are, your risk tolerance levels, and a lot more. So choosing one over the other will depend on what you seek as an investor and your investing behavior. It is important to note that the exit load could be applicable if you redeem the investment within a specified period. On the other hand, ETFs do not have any specified buying or selling time. ETFs do not aim to create alpha over the benchmark index that it tracks; it aims to replicate the returns of the benchmark index.

This unit versus amount context has a bearing on the minimum investment one needs to put up when purchasing either of these financial products. Like in ETFs, most trading platforms allow their investors to buy even a single unit. For instance, a single unit of the ICICI Prudential Bharat 22 ETF can cost you about Rs. 40.

Help Me Invest

Systematic investment plans or SIPs are rightly credited for the huge surge in the popularity of mutual fund investment in India. By choosing to set aside a certain amount each month, you can significantly build long-term wealth through the power of compounding. Moreover, SIP promotes a financially healthy habit of investing regularly. Each time you wish to invest in an ETF, you will need to do it deliberately, which can be cumbersome and easy to miss. Some ETFs offer a DRIP, and some brokers will handle dividend reinvestment for their clients as well. Still, ETF investors will have to wait for dividend payments to settle in their brokerage account before they’re reinvested, which means waiting an extra three days.

Why ETFs are better than index funds?

ETFs may be more accessible and easy to trade for retail investors as they trade like shares of stock on exchanges. They also tend to have lower fees and are more tax-efficient, on average.

ETFs enjoy a smaller market of buyers and sellers and can be less liquid as compared to Index funds and other mutual funds. Index fund investments can be easily liquidated since the AMC is bound to buy/sell mutual fund units. • Benefit of a Systematic Investment Plans is not available in ETFs, while Index funds allow SIPs. ETFs require the investors to invest a minimum amount of INR 10,000, and they do not get the option to invest in SIPs. The ETF investment strategy used by the investor could be active trading on the exchange for short-term investment or a long-term horizon.

What are the different types of index funds available in India?

ETFs, as mentioned, are generally more tax-efficient than index mutual funds. Since an ETF is sold on an exchange, that means there has to be a buyer for every share sold. An ETF is a basket of stocks that reflects the composition of an Index, like S&P CNX Nifty or BSE Sensex. The ETFs trading value is based on the net asset value of the underlying stocks that it represents. Think of it as a Mutual Fund that you can buy and sell in real-time at a price that change throughout the day.

Like in case of index funds, Index ETFs also are charged STCG at 15% and LTCG at 0%. Pay 20% upfront margin of the transaction value to trade in cash market segment. For example, currently, the Nifty is quoting at 11,450 so an ETF which represents 1/10th unit of Nifty will be quoting in the market around the absolute value of 1,145. This ETF vs index fund India debate is predicated on 5 factors. Having a good management does not get enough credit in our valuation models. Investors usually focus on a company’s PE ratio, earnings growth, return on equity etc. is important.

etfs vs index funds

There are various kinds of ETFs available in India, right from gold ETFs to Nifty and Sensex. There are also CPSE and Bharat 22 ETFs, which give exposure to public sector companies. There are also niche ETFs called factor-based ETFs; for example, low-volatility and value ETFs. However, experts suggest that only evolved investors should dabble in these niche offerings. An ETF investor who wants to invest about $500 in the same fund every month but pays a $5 commission on every trade is essentially paying a 1% fee right off the bat for their investment. That said, this “fee” will drop as the investor’s stake in the ETF grows.

Why invest in ETFs?

Many investors are aware of the benefits of diversifying their portfolio across assets. Index funds often catch their eyes in this search as they refer to funds that invest in a wider market index – like the Sensex or the Nifty. All the stocks in these indices will find some representation in their investment portfolio. This theoretically ensures a performance identical to that of the index which is being tracked. Mutual funds, whether index funds or any other, are investment vehicles that are made up of pooled funds.

Investors don’t necessarily have to pick either an Index fund or an ETF. Both these put together can also make for an ideal investment portfolio that offers diversification, the right amount of stock market exposure, and sustainable long-term returns. Dividend Payouts – With ETFs, the dividend gets credited to the investor’s bank account and this can be manually reinvested later.

What is the difference between ETFs and actively managed Mutual funds?

• In mutual funds, the AMC acts as counterparty to the investor. Investors do their buy / sell transactions with the AMC whereas ETFs are listed on stock exchanges like shares. Investors can buy or sell ETFs in the stock exchange at a real time price.

• Mutual fund NAVs are priced at the end of the day. However, just like shares, ETF prices change real time throughout the day based on demand and supply in the market.

• You can invest in mutual funds directly through AMC or through an AMFI certified mutual fund distributors (MFD). However, to invest in ETFs, it is mandatory to have a demat and trading account with a stock broker.

• ETFs do not aim to create alpha over the benchmark index that it tracks; it aims to replicate the returns of the benchmark index.

• Being passive funds, the ETF expense ratios are much lower compared to actively managed mutual fund schemes.

F&O positions are marked to market and in case of market correction; investors may have to provide additional money for maintaining margin even before expiry. ETFs are not leveraged positions and hence there is no margin requirement. During market correction, your ETF NAV will fall but you will not have to pay any additional money. The indices, which by their method of construction based on market capitalization, eliminate or at least, reduce the weight of underperformers in the index portfolio.

This is certainly not much of a concern for long-term investors. But if you are an investor who looks to time the market, then that is where an ETF comes in handy with features like intraday trading, stop losses, order limits, etc. Both ETFs and index funds can help you earn decent returns in the long run; however, the latter can be a better option if you are looking for a convenient mode of investment.

etfs vs index funds

Let’s take a detailed look at index funds vs ETFs to assess which may work for you. His belief is not without basis – more than 90% of large cap companies in the US failed to beat the S&P 500 index over long investment tenor. forex brokers However, they have a higher expense ratio due to higher transaction fees or commission as compared to ETFs. Edelweiss Broking Ltd. acts in the capacity of distributor for Products such as OFS, Mutual Funds, IPOs and NCD etc.

  • The stocks mentioned in this article are not recommendations.
  • On the other hand, to transact in ETFs, you will need a DEMAT account and a share trading account since they are traded on exchanges similar to stocks.
  • Truthfully, both index funds and ETFs have their upsides and downsides.
  • ETFs generally have a lower expense ratio than that of Index funds.

● Investors can buy as little as one share as there is no minimum investment requirement. ETFs come with higher liquidity because they do not involve daily trading volume. ETFs offer multiple tax benefits to the investors because of the way of their redemption and creation. Our services are non-advised however, we may facilitate providing you with required advice through eligible third-party providers. We recommend that the same must be reviewed independently by the customers.

Of course, in reality there will be a minor divergence to reflect costs. 4) No need to issue cheques by investors while subscribing to IPO. When you buy an index fund from an AMC , it adds to the AUM of the fund, and when you redeem your units the AUM reduces. How to Use Fibonacci The net effect each day will either increase or decrease the AUM. For an Index ETF you can buy or sell only if there is counterparty to the trade. So, liquidity is the key in index ETFs and their AUM will only increase when the value of the shares go up.

Leave a Comment

Het e-mailadres wordt niet gepubliceerd. Vereiste velden zijn gemarkeerd met *